Saturday, April 21, 2012

Slaughter

In college I was a hell raiser advocate for humane slaughter of horses in the United States for a very long, very in depth list of reasons. Flame me if you will, but there's a disgusting over population of horses in the United States due to a lack of any sort of breeding regulations and something needs to be done about it. However, my past reasons for my beliefs are not what this post is about.

Horse slaughter to me, was always something that happened far far away in Mexico, or some Temple Grandin approved fuzzy wuzzy processing plant in Wisconsin or something. It was something that would never happen in Vermont, and something that I knew I'd never had to deal with personally- so why worry?

Unfortunately, I've been recently slapped in the face with a side of German European reality that gives me a disgusting knot in my stomach that I can't seem to shake, no matter what I tell myself. Through a variety of reasons at my job, we're downsizing our school horses. We've sent one off already, and the next two on the axe list are my driving team of horses- Ben and Boris. Basically, they have a week to be placed in a home and if not, they're going on a one way ride.

I have a lot of problems with this. Most of it stems from emotional attachment, and there's reasons why I feel that this is grossly unfair. The reasons are directly job related, but I won't turn this into a bitch fest of 'OH GOD, WHY THESE HORSES!?!?!'. The point is, when is slaughter truly justified? 

I always believed that I'd rather see a horse have a quick, humane end than go to a home of hill billy American who don't know the first thing about owning a horse and end up abusing and neglecting it until it dies a slow, horrible, fear ridden death. But Ben and Boris aren't lame, aren't terribly old, and they're perfect for beginners for riding or driving. There's nothing wrong with the pair, they're perfectly healthy, and they've never put a foot wrong. There's also a strong sense of emotional attachment here, so I'll admit, I am really biased in my points.

Over here, in Europe, there's very strict breeding regulations and horse slaughter is a normal and perfectly acceptable thing. There's no over population of horses, no dilapidated trailers housing fifteen horses on one acre, no Craigslist ads for 'kid friendly' stud horses of questionable parentage, and definitely no horse sanctuaries that are just giant holes that people throw large amounts of money into. Horses are treated fairly, and are given the respect that they deserve. Sick and old horses are turned out to pasture to roll around and frolic until their last day on earth.

So when is it acceptable to send a horse to slaughter? What qualifications should a horse possess to have that kind of fate? Should he be old? Perpetually lame? Dangerous? Unwanted? Where is that line that determines that this horse should die and this horse should live?

I know that we can't save them all, and this is a subject that we generally turn a blind eye to. If we can save one horse from slaughter, we write about how this is a true story of redemption and that this horse is a miracle, or some sort of sappy shit like that. But what about the other horses? Why raise one up and forget about the others?

I've suddenly come to realize that 98% of this debate is emotional attachment to horses. The truth is, we don't look at horses as livestock. We don't see them on the same level as a cow, or a pig, or a sheep. We put them up with dogs, cats, and other humans. There's a line between livestock and house pets and somehow the horse manages to fulfill both categories quite well. It's also the social norm to look at horses as house pets, because if I were to say that I look at horses as livestock I'd be instantly labeled as cold, cruel, and uncaring.

For example, pigs, cows and sheep have numbered I.D. tags pierced into their ears. Horses, dogs, and sometimes cats have a name, and some sort of polished metal plate and receive treats, massages, and grooming sessions. There's this hierarchy of animals that we've established with our emotions and the way that the animal makes us feel. I mean, let's be real here, when have you felt especially close to a cow from your neighbors farm? 

It's not a fuzzy world out there, and sooner or later there's going to be a large dose of reality shoved down your hatch weather you're ready to accept it or not. It's just a matter of swallowing and coping, because there's way too many emotions involved to sort out the tangle and try to make some sort of order out of this mess. I used to think that there was a clear solution to the slaughter debate as long as I didn't have to be directly involved with the slaughter itself. Now, I just see that it's just a complicated debate that will never, ever end. It's just this giant emotional monster that you either accept, or you try to fight and end up on the losing front in a variety of ways. 

2 comments:

  1. I am thoroughly against horses that have worked honestly for a living and for their humans' benefit going to slaughter unless they are ancient/crippled. It just doesn't seem right, all other slaughter issues aside. :(

    ReplyDelete
  2. you didn't mention the method of slaughter here in germany. are there largescale slaughter houses in germany designed for slaughtering large numbers of horses every day? i honestly don't know but i know that there are common alternatives to this. i think it's fascinating, the differences - the lack of widespread neglect due to the fact that horses mostly live in riding stables, not in someone's backyard. and this tattle-tale society wouldn't allow the neglect that we have in america.

    ReplyDelete